Desk: World News Ref: GG-4313 4 min read
■ World News DOC: GG-4313

Supreme Court Rejects Trump Bid to Make California Set Aside Ballots

The Supreme Court denied a Justice Department request to make California set aside mail ballots from about 20,000 people the administration calls likely noncitizens, one day before Election Day.

Supreme Court of the United States - Philosophical Swag
File photo: Philosophicalswag / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday denied a Justice Department request to set aside California mail ballots from about 20,000 people the administration calls likely noncitizens, one day before Election Day.

The one-line order was unsigned and gave no reasons, CBS News reported. No justices noted a dissent, CBS reported.

The administration filed its application only hours before the order, NBC News reported. The court did not ask California officials to respond first, according to CBS.

What the Justice Department asked for

The department sought an injunction that would have required California to segregate the ballots, and not tabulate them, until the voters’ citizenship was confirmed, CBS reported. The administration sent letters on the matter to all 58 California counties, CBS said.

California has more than 23 million registered voters. CBS reported that more than 6 million mail ballots had been returned. Election Day is Tuesday, Nov. 3.

The administration relied on a federal law that bars noncitizens from voting, arguing that it allows intervention in state-run elections, NBC reported. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals found no evidence that Congress intended that law to pre-empt state election laws, NBC reported.

How the case moved through the courts

The Justice Department sued California officials in mid-October, Al Jazeera reported. The table below sets out the three rulings that followed, with details from Al Jazeera, CBS News and NBC Bay Area.

DateCourtResult
Oct. 269th U.S. Circuit Court of AppealsA 2-1 panel declined the request
Oct. 28U.S. District Court, Central District of CaliforniaJudge David O. Carter denied a temporary restraining order
Nov. 2U.S. Supreme CourtEmergency application denied in an unsigned order

Judge Gabriel Sanchez, writing for the 9th Circuit majority, said the administration had not given lower courts enough time to review the request and that elections are a state matter. He described the subject as one “squarely within the state’s traditional domain,” Al Jazeera reported.

Carter said on Wednesday that segregating ballots would effectively purge voters, and he cited the 90-day bar on voter-roll changes before an election, NBC Bay Area reported.

He called the process “rife with uncertainty and errors,” CBS reported.

Bill Essayli, the first assistant U.S. attorney, disagreed. “Segregating a ballot does not prevent it from being counted later,” he said, NBC Bay Area reported.

The Justice Department said it would appeal immediately, NBC Bay Area reported. It then went to the Supreme Court, according to CBS.

Why timing mattered for California mail ballots

NBC reported that once ballots are processed, it would be impossible to determine afterward which votes may have been cast by the alleged noncitizens. After signature checks, voter-identifying details are discarded, NBC reported.

Carter made a similar point about harm. “Eroded trust in our democracy is irreparable. Once a vote is segregated, lasting harm has occurred,” he said, NBC Bay Area reported.

Disputes over the list

California Attorney General Rob Bonta’s office said Los Angeles County completed a preliminary review of 200 names from the list and found that more than half had canceled or inactive registrations. It said 38.9% listed a U.S. birthplace and 71.2% had no voting history.

Mendocino County found that every name on its list lived outside the county, Bonta’s office said. It added that the administration had earlier claimed about 190,000 noncitizens were on the rolls before cutting the figure to about 20,000.

Bonta said in a statement on Oct. 26 that evidence from counts, recounts, hand counts and audits shows that voter fraud is “exceedingly rare.”

Lawyers for California Secretary of State Shirley Weber wrote in an Oct. 20 filing that “at best, this litigation is a reckless political stunt,” Al Jazeera reported.

The Justice Department’s record

A Reuters count found 129 federal cases of noncitizens charged with illegal voting since 1996, Al Jazeera reported.

Al Jazeera also reported that the department has filed voter-roll lawsuits against 30 states and the District of Columbia, has won none and has lost 26.

Disputes in other states

The department demanded that Washington Secretary of State Steve Hobbs set aside the ballots of more than 400 people, CBS reported. Hobbs said the list included many U.S. citizens, CBS reported. NBC reported that the federal government had called 185 people in Nevada noncitizens, and the state said all 185 were citizens.

A federal judge on Saturday told the department to stop threatening California officials with prosecution, NBC reported. An Alaska lawsuit over certification was dismissed on Sunday, CBS reported.

What happens next

Election Day is Tuesday, Nov. 3. The Justice Department said last week it would appeal the district court ruling immediately, NBC Bay Area reported.

Sources

Share X Facebook

Comments (1)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *